tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3015183155330967608.post3377745765726105163..comments2013-08-14T05:37:56.903-07:00Comments on psquared to the nth: American Idol -- Top 9 Reduxp²http://www.blogger.com/profile/17000504448114915783noreply@blogger.comBlogger5125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3015183155330967608.post-19645414271831213422010-04-15T11:54:41.803-07:002010-04-15T11:54:41.803-07:00I have not been following as closely as last year,...I have not been following as closely as last year, so I am even more grateful for your recaps! I am glad you recognized Adam. I thought he gave some really good constructive advice. "Give the audience something to look at, listen to, and feel" is great advice! Also, re: the judges...I find myself looking forward to Kara's comments the most. Whether I agree or not, she has really come into her own. Where as I find that Randy and Simon come across as schtick and catchphrases, she is rather constructive. This season I find I am watching out of loyalty, but thus far this is the first year when none of the contestants stand out enough for me to want to buy anything from any of them and I don't think I have sat through a complete group number before hitting the FF button. It seems like an long painful limp to the final three which will be Crystal, Casey, and Lee. I kinda wish they would get rid of two next week too - Miss ya!Marvinnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3015183155330967608.post-11026518072483475822010-04-14T12:11:06.682-07:002010-04-14T12:11:06.682-07:00boy, was i typing fast! "so were lee"???...boy, was i typing fast! "so were lee"???? and of course the save week "comes" with "the" awful reality...Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3015183155330967608.post-27527949335515041602010-04-14T12:10:31.108-07:002010-04-14T12:10:31.108-07:00boy, was i typing fast! "so were lee"???...boy, was i typing fast! "so were lee"???? and of course the save week "comes" with "the" awful reality...Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3015183155330967608.post-66429906728280754382010-04-14T12:08:11.433-07:002010-04-14T12:08:11.433-07:00janet here -- i think you are right. it's the ...janet here -- i think you are right. it's the end of the line tonight for andrew and katie. and your observation about the morale boost of the save week coms with awful reality the next week that two people go home. this must be a heckuva scary week for them so i wonder if the save week is worth it. crystal was dynamite as usual and so were lee. they are now my absolutely two favorites. i'm not sure what is up with siobhan right now. i found that version a little dull and i worry that despite her inspirational little speech about just loving to sing and not needing to stick to one type of thing, that in reality simon is dead on. no matter what you have to show us the artist you will be post-idol. i thought siobhan had a clear vision of that but the last few weeks have made me rethink it. simon was right when he said in a catalog that big you can pick a song that represents what you might record on an album (or something like that). you don't just go for your favorite. i thought adam lambert did a great job as the mentor because he was absolutely honest about not liking something. i think in a surprise tonight, it could be casey in the bottom three but ultimately he will be safe.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3015183155330967608.post-39499667303742017282010-04-14T11:48:40.336-07:002010-04-14T11:48:40.336-07:00I'm totally over Garcia! And I'm surprise...I'm totally over Garcia! And I'm surprised you don't like Big Mike. I actually think he's among the better of those who are left!Kellyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12700373533249458292noreply@blogger.com